Skip to content
Fashion Tips

The Noir Rivalry: Black Bikinis vs. Black One Piece Swimsuit - Who is the winner?

By Rachel Kius5 min read
The Sculpting C In Black Compression from Tropic of C
Image: Tropic of C Website
Back to Fashion Tips

A Battle of Elegance in Monochromatic Waters

Ah, the enduring allure of the black one-piece swimsuit, reminiscent of that timeless little black dress hanging in every fashionista’s closet. It’s the perennial darling of swimwear, effortlessly straddling the fine line between sophistication and sensuality. But have you ever considered the black bikini as its equally chic counterpart? Much like the black one-piece swimsuit, the black bikini is a must-have in any discerning swimwear arsenal.

Timeless and Chic: Our Top Black Swimwear Picks

In this article, we will explore the world of black swimwear and compare the versatility and style of black bikinis and black one-piece swimsuits. We’ll dive into the details of each swimwear style, highlighting their unique features and benefits. So, let’s get started and find out who will emerge as the ultimate winner in the noir rivalry.

Bonita Nero - One-Piece Swimsuit from Sommer Swim
Sommer Swim Website
Mika Top and Pastis Bottom from Janthee Berlin
Janthee Berlin Website
Seafolly Collective Boyleg One Piece from Seafolly
Seafolly Website

Same

Let’s kick off our swimwear journey with the Same Rose Bandeau Top and Rose 90S Bottom. This swimwear set is the epitome of understated elegance. The bandeau top and 90s-style bottom create a flattering silhouette. But what truly sets this bikini apart is the hand-made three-dimensional rose bloom. It’s a delicate and feminine detail that adds a whimsical touch to the overall design.

Rose bandeau top faux suede black & Rose 90s bottom faux suede black

Bikini · sold separately

Rose Bandeau Top and Rose 90S Bottom from SameSame Website
Rose Bandeau Top and Rose 90S Bottom from SameSame Website
1 / 2
Top no longer available
Bottom no longer available

Seafolly

Next up, we have the Collective Boyleg One Piece. This swimsuit is the epitome of chic swimwear. The boyleg legline adds a touch of retro flair, while the ruched panel adds a flattering detail to the overall silhouette. This swimsuit is not only stylish but also functional, with an internal shelf bra for bust support and soft cups for shape and support. Made from 80% recycled nylon and 20% elastane, this swimsuit is also environmentally conscious.

collective boyleg one piece 10316 942 black

One-piece

Seafolly Collective Boyleg One Piece from SeafollySeafolly Website
Seafolly Collective Boyleg One Piece from SeafollySeafolly Website
Seafolly Collective Boyleg One Piece from SeafollySeafolly Website
Seafolly Collective Boyleg One Piece from SeafollySeafolly Website
1 / 4

Sommer Swim - Chic Separates

Now, let’s look at the Rylee Nero and Sadie Nero swimwear separates from Sommer Swim. These pieces are the epitome of chic and sophisticated beach attire. The underwire balconette top provides both support and a flattering shape. The adjustable straps allow for a customizable fit, and the ruched front and side detailing add a touch of femininity. The gold clip closure adds a luxurious touch to the overall design. What sets this bikini apart is its versatility - the removable straps transform the Rylee top into a bandeau, perfect for sunbathing.

Rylee nero balconette bikini top & Sadie nero brazilian bikini bottoms

Bikini · sold separately

Rylee Nero and Sadie Nero from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Rylee Nero and Sadie Nero from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Rylee Nero and Sadie Nero from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Rylee Nero and Sadie Nero from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
1 / 4
Top no longer available
Bottom no longer available

Sommer Swim - The Cut-Out Masterpiece

Continuing with Sommer Swim, it’s impossible not to be utterly captivated by the cut-out design of the Bonita Nero – a true masterpiece in swimwear design. This one-shouldered one-piece boasts a central cut-out feature, coupled with a daring cheeky cut, offering both low coverage and a high-cut style. The gold hardware details add a touch of luxury and elevate the overall look.

Bonita nero one piece swimsuit

One-piece

Bonita Nero - One-Piece Swimsuit from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Bonita Nero - One-Piece Swimsuit from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Bonita Nero - One-Piece Swimsuit from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
Bonita Nero - One-Piece Swimsuit from Sommer SwimSommer Swim Website
1 / 4
No longer available

TA3

TA3Swim is an innovative new brand that promises to smooth, sculpt, and flatter your figure with its sleek one-piece styles.

The Plungey swimsuit is probably the most iconic piece from this new brand. With adjustable straps, removable bust pads, and an ultra-supportive shelf bra, the Plungey is designed to fit and flatter every body type.

Plungey black

One-piece

Plungey from ta3swimta3swim Website
Plungey from ta3swimta3swim Website
Plungey from ta3swimta3swim Website
Plungey from ta3swimta3swim Website
1 / 4

Tropic of C - My Sculpting Favorite

Since I’ve recommended a figure-sculpting swimsuit like TA3Swim, I can’t help but mention this one-piece from Tropic Of C. I must admit it’s my favorite… so much so that I’ve chosen it as the cover photo for this article. Candice Swanepoel, the founder of Tropic of C, looks as fantastic as ever in this swimsuit, which, in its apparent simplicity, is a genuine work of art.

Made with ECONYL® regenerated nylon and sustainable compression fabric, this swimsuit is a fantastic choice for your wardrobe. With its superior strength, muscle compression, and UV protection, this suit is perfect for those who want to feel confident and stylish while enjoying the sun. Remember to size up as it runs small.

The c eco in black

One-piece

The Sculpting C In Black Compression from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
The Sculpting C In Black Compression from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
The Sculpting C In Black Compression from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
The Sculpting C In Black Compression from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
1 / 4

Tropic of C - A Touch of ’90s Nostalgia

If you find the Sculpting C design too plain and would rather have something with a touch of 90s nostalgia, but still from Tropic of C and crafted with ECONYL, then check out the High Twist One Piece. It features a more intricate pattern and its twisted cut-outs and gold hardware details, exude a sense of effortless cool.

High twist one piece in black terra

One-piece

High Twist One Piece In Black Terra from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
High Twist One Piece In Black Terra from Tropic of CTropic of C Website
1 / 2
No longer available

Janthee Berlin

The Janthee Berlin Mika Top and Pastis Bottom is a swimwear duo that exudes a sleek lingerie-inspired style. The triangle top with adjustable straps ensures a perfect fit, while the bottom boasts a tantalizing opening detail. Janthee Berlin’s attention to detail is evident in the adjustable panels, allowing for a customizable look. Janthee Berlin has truly mastered the art of creating bikinis that are both sexy and sophisticated.

Mika top black & Pastis bottom black

Bikini · sold separately

Mika Top and Pastis Bottom from Janthee BerlinJanthee Berlin Website
Mika Top and Pastis Bottom from Janthee BerlinJanthee Berlin Website
Mika Top and Pastis Bottom from Janthee BerlinJanthee Berlin Website
Mika Top and Pastis Bottom from Janthee BerlinJanthee Berlin Website
1 / 4

White Fox Boutique

For a swimsuit that combines sophistication with a playful twist, look no further than the White Fox Colombia One Piece. The cross-over neck detail and open back with tie add a touch of elegance, while the open chest design and cut-out sides add a hint of allure. This swimsuit is perfect for those who want to make a statement by the pool or at the beach.

Colombia one piece black

One-piece

Colombia One Piece from White FoxWhite Fox Website
Colombia One Piece from White FoxWhite Fox Website
Colombia One Piece from White FoxWhite Fox Website
Colombia One Piece from White FoxWhite Fox Website
1 / 4

Maaji

The Bandeau Onyx Ursule V Wire top and Sublimity Onyx bottoms represent the epitome of chic in the world of Maaji swimwear, the famous Colombian brand known for its reversible swimwear offering. The reversible feature is a true game-changer, giving you two looks in one. As for today’s proposal, we’re sticking with the black side, but the colorful pattern on the reversible part is truly intriguing. The carefully crafted details and the use of recycled fibers showcase Maaji’s commitment to quality and sustainability.

Ursule V Wire Bandeau Bikini Top & Sublimity Classic Bikini Bottom - Onyx

Bikini · sold separately

Maaji Onyx Ursule V Wire Bandeau Bikini Top and Maaji Onyx Sublimity Classic Bikini Bottom from MaajiMaaji Website
Maaji Onyx Ursule V Wire Bandeau Bikini Top and Maaji Onyx Sublimity Classic Bikini Bottom from MaajiMaaji Website
Maaji Onyx Ursule V Wire Bandeau Bikini Top and Maaji Onyx Sublimity Classic Bikini Bottom from MaajiMaaji Website
Maaji Onyx Ursule V Wire Bandeau Bikini Top and Maaji Onyx Sublimity Classic Bikini Bottom from MaajiMaaji Website
1 / 4
Top no longer available
Bottom no longer available

Marysia

Let’s move on to the Broadway Top and High Antibes Bottom, a swimwear duo that exudes effortless chic. Sold as separates, this bikini in classic black is a must-have for any beach lover. The triangle top, a timeless silhouette, is elevated by Marysia’s signature hand-cut, raw edge scalloped trim. With adjustable ties at the neck and back, it offers a customizable fit for ultimate comfort. The high-waisted Antibes bottom complements the top beautifully, creating a flattering and stylish look.

Broadway top in black & High antibes bottom in black indigo

Bikini · sold separately

Broadway Top and High Antibes Bottom from MarysiaMarysia Website
Broadway Top and High Antibes Bottom from MarysiaMarysia Website
Broadway Top and High Antibes Bottom from MarysiaMarysia Website
Broadway Top and High Antibes Bottom from MarysiaMarysia Website
1 / 4

Onia

The bandeau-style top is padded and underwired, providing both comfort and support. The adjustable back closure ensures a perfect fit for every body shape. But what sets this set apart is the sheer, ribbed-mesh overlay on the top, featuring a high neck and a cutout back. The tonal trims add a subtle touch of sophistication. Made from nylon tricot, the Alex Bikini Top and Sabrina Bikini Bottom are designed to flatter and enhance your natural curves.

Alex bikini top - Black & Sabrina bikini bottom

Bikini · sold separately

Alex Bikini Top and Sabrina Bikini Bottom from OniaOnia Website
Alex Bikini Top and Sabrina Bikini Bottom from OniaOnia Website
Alex Bikini Top and Sabrina Bikini Bottom from OniaOnia Website
Alex Bikini Top and Sabrina Bikini Bottom from OniaOnia Website
1 / 4
Top no longer available
Bottom no longer available

PatBO

Let’s head back to South America and dive into the offerings of Patricia Bonaldi, the Brazilian founder of PatBo. Her offerings are never ordinary, and this bikini with its asymmetric design on the bottoms and a bandeau top is no exception. The addition of a white ring to embellish the bikini is sublime and adds an extra touch of elegance. I’m in love…

Bandeau bikini top & Mid rise bikini bottom - Black

Bikini · sold separately

Bandeau Bikini Top and Mid-Rise Bikini Bottom from PatBOPatBO Website
Bandeau Bikini Top and Mid-Rise Bikini Bottom from PatBOPatBO Website
Bandeau Bikini Top and Mid-Rise Bikini Bottom from PatBOPatBO Website
Bandeau Bikini Top and Mid-Rise Bikini Bottom from PatBOPatBO Website
1 / 4
Top no longer available
Bottom no longer available

Reina Olga

Last but certainly not least, we have the Showpony swimsuit by Reina Olga. This swimsuit is the epitome of poolside glamour. With its sleek black color and cut-out design, it exudes sophistication and style. Perfect for lounging by the pool or sipping champagne on the beach, this swimsuit is a must-have for those who prefer to look fabulous rather than engage in physical activity. Pair it with hot pants for an even more stunning ensemble. Reina Olga has truly created a piece that embodies luxury and elegance.

New showpony swimsuit black

One-piece

Showpony Swimsuit from Reina OlgaReina Olga Website
Showpony Swimsuit from Reina OlgaReina Olga Website
Showpony Swimsuit from Reina OlgaReina Olga Website
Showpony Swimsuit from Reina OlgaReina Olga Website
1 / 4
No longer available

Conclusion

In conclusion, the noir rivalry between black bikinis and black one-piece swimsuits is a tough one to call. Today, I’ve presented to you 7 different bikinis and 7 different one-piece swimsuits, each with its characteristics. As you have surely understood, there can’t be a single winner. For swimwear enthusiasts like myself, black swimwear is a timeless choice that will never go out of style, and I never go on vacation without at least a couple of them.

I’ve offered you various options, and each of the swimsuits I’ve presented is a fantastic choice: from my (I admit) favorite Sculpting C to the surprising design of Reina Olga that looks like a bikini until you turn around to discover it’s a one-piece.

Beyond these, on the website, you can find other options to make your wardrobe perfect. Bye for now…

Keep reading

More from Fashion Tips